A new study by the Clean Label Project found that several protein powders contain toxins that are harmful to your health. Considering there was a series of studies funded by Consumer Reports in 2010 to test metals and toxins in mostly animal based supplements and the results where terrible, I see two possibilities here. Clean Label Project™ completed a study of 134 protein powder products from 52 brands. I also notice Cleanlabelproject selectively leaves out any LENTEIN TM based plant proteins (its a legume, i think, that's grown floating in a purified water vat not in the ground)... Can't help but wonder why...? 2018-03-01 02:06 PM PST Your recent chat with Vega - Shannon Vega - Shannon Hi there! You- I just read the report indicating that the Vega sports protein powder that I've been using for years, EXCEEDS the california daily allowable limit for heavy metals! In March of 2018, Consumer Reports released an alarming article talking about high levels of heavy metal contamination (arsenic, lead, cadmium, and mercury) in popular protein powders. Visit PureMarket.com for the full study details, and to see a list of all ranked products used to create Pure Market’s benchmarked results. BOTH the animal and plant based proteins had dangerous levels of metals and toxins, through explaining merely where the animal protein stood in proportion to the plant protein hides the danger of both while making the animal protein look better when in reality both are dangerous. The top five products the Clean Label Project identified were Puori, BioChem and … US nonprofit Clean Label Project has defended the techniques it used to produce a controversial study of popular protein powders.. The Clean Label Project recently tested 131 of America’s best selling animal-derived and plant-based protein powders for heavy metals (arsenic, cadmium, lead, and mercury), over 100 pesticides, BPA/BPS (plasticizers that are known endocrine disruptors), residual solvents, mycotoxins, melamine and its analogues, and antibiotics residues. As an American living in England, I cried and yelled and threw shit for weeks dealing with people not being able to solve problems they caused me or give me information that was simple or be competent. At Vega the trust and safety of our consumers is our top priority. Clean Label Project has seen elevated levels of heavy metals including Arsenic, Cadmium, Lead, and Mercury as well as BPA leaching from packaging into the finished product. They have enlisted the help of Clean Label Project to go into the marketplace and randomly purchase and test their products to ensure that they continue to live up to these high standards. It's not a personal attack or them saying no to you, they can't just call the guy up and be like hey this person is unhappy it just doesn't seem to work like that. Clean Label Project, the national nonprofit focused on health and transparency in product labeling, just completed a study of 134 of the top-selling protein powders in North America. Vega - Shannon As mentioned, I have provided the extent of information that we have at the moment. Vega - Shannon As mentioned, our certificates of analysis and records are not something we are able to provide. For the sake of clarity, where can I locate a certificate of batch analysis to determine for myself the risk I have ingested? Vega - Shannon I will pass your feedback on to our team. Thorne Whey Protein Isolate is a clean product that’s low in sugar, calories, and fat. All of this is kept from public view while they simply declare, barely asserting the conclusion of the study results while all the context is kept behind lock and key. A lot of people are entitled and expect things to be handled but seriously so many people whole countries corporations are filled with incompetence. Thank you for writing in. Where can I locate my batch number and your corresponding records to determine this? Here’s a sneak peek at their findings of the WORST brands on the market (based on products tested*). Stay tuned as more brands are currently going through the Certification Process. the clean label project report on protein powders videos and latest news articles; GlobalNews.ca your source for the latest news on the clean label project report on protein powders . Clean Label Project™ 280 E. 1st Ave. #873 Broomfield, CO 80038-0873 Clean Label Project™ is a 501(c)3 tax-exempt organization Clean Label Project is committed to changing the definition of food and consumer safety through data, science, and transparency. At Vega the trust and safety of our consumers is our top priority. They found that 53 of the 134 protein powders tested with elevated levels of lead, mercury, arsenic, cadmium, and BPA. You- Great, that sounds like a company line if I ever heard one "we were made aware". But not by being outraged you didn't get a personal contact or information directly from them or them solving it or even really caring. The entire thing is strange, while I can understand why they wouldn't want to just hand info to a random customer or bother another employee with every request. They referenced a major study done by the Clean Label Project in which 134 of the best selling protein powders were tested and examined for quality in many facets. Clean Label Project Purity Award Winning brands have voluntarily and proactively implemented procedures to ensure ingredient quality and purity. Doesn't mean I'm going to go to the ends of the Earth because they won't let me talk to their head of whatever. Clean Label Project (CLP) is using the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standard for drinking water to compare against pet foods. The Clean Label Project, a nonprofit group that focuses on transparency in product labeling, conducted the study. In its recent analysis of plant-based protein powders, the Clean Label Project assigned each product a score based on four criteria: heavy metals, pesticides, contaminants like BPA, and nutrition. The heavy metal … In recent years, few protein powder brands have earned awards as a result of their commitment to doing better than the industry by going above and beyond minimum food safety requirements. You can see the results at the Clean Label Project's website (www.cleanlabelproject.org). Organic Consumers Association and Clean Label Project used the Amazon.com bestsellers list and Clean Label Project 2018’s protein powder investigation results as sources for the 28 products chosen for the study. Clean Label Project is committed to changing the definition of food and consumer safety through data, science, and transparency. All programs require unannounced retail product sampling and … Unfortunately if your not a proponent for your own safety, the government doesn't have your back in the supplement industry. The Clean Label Project measured the levels of heavy metals, BPA, pesticides, and other contaminants (more than 150 in all) in protein powders and … Vega - Shannon We appreciate your concern, and I can pass your feedback on to our team. We have recently tested the protein powder industry to see how clean protein powder is. I am unable to forward you to a representative from our Quality Team at this time. Plants absorb naturally occurring minerals from the soil which can be reflected in the final product. We have been made aware of a recent report released by the Clean Label Project on protein powders. 280 E. 1st Ave. #873 We were surprised by the presented conclusions. Knowing people that work in government positions, public servants, despite their jobs not being so public facing positions are still often paralyzed by constant public inquiries, calls about pure nonsense and conspiracy quackery, requests of information they are required by law to oblige (like requesting every email and text you sent in a year etc.) this often brings work to a stand still and becomes debilitating. I'll be publishing this, until you can clearly demonstrate you are in compliance with safety standards. Like is it just me? What can you tell me about this??? Make sure others know by not recommending the brand, warn people by saying hey it has this in it. The Clean Label Project award program is based on food and consumer product safety issues that consumers are increasingly caring about- heavy metals, pesticide residues, and plasticizers, other chemicals of concern, and truth in labeling. High levels of heavy metals, BPA, pesticides and other toxins associated with cancer were found in the 134 protein powder products, from 52 … A new study by the Clean Label Project suggests that some of the most popular protein products on the market may contain contaminants. That said, we have not seen the raw data on which Clean Label Project based their report, or the full methodology they used, so we can’t comment on this particular report at this point in time. We are proud that Vega products are made with only real, whole food plant-based ingredients condensed into one nutrient-dense scoop. When it comes to protein powders, consumers are looking for clean protein to complement their already healthy lifestyle choices. That’s my conclusion after reviewing the Clean Label Project’s wildly unscientific attack on protein products such as VEGA, where the Clean Label Project seems to insinuate that […] It should be at the top of their five star list... but .. nada. You- I presume you sample every batch and use some analytical GMP processes which you can transparently provide to your consumers. Broomfield, CO 80038-0873, The Best & Worst Prenatal Vitamin Products. No artificial or synthetic ingredients are used in our products. You- Ok, thanks for providing that lack of transparency. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Our robust Quality Assurance programs ensure our products are compliant with our own rigorous internal standards, as well as all government regulations. The Clean Label Project conducted a study with the top selling protein powders, powders you can find in most retail store and websites. In the case that they don't, an inquiry into their Quality department is warranted. Sorry this might not be what was the expected response since you were upset by this. We have recently tested the protein powder industry to see how clean protein powder is. I think because of the previous CR study in 2010 it's more likely BOTH are dangerous, but one cannot know because no ones willing to show us their results or methodology. Products with egg as a protein source, however, tested cleaner. The certificates of analysis and records are proprietary. *Products Tested: Dymatize ISO 100 Whey Protein Powder Isolate – Gourmet Chocolate (725 g); Dymatize Elite Fusion 7 Protein Blend – Orange Creamsicle (907 g); Vega Sport Premium Plant-Based Protein Powder – Vanilla (828 g); Vega One All-in-One Plant Based Protein Powder – Mixed Berry (425 g); Vega Sport Premium Plant-Based Protein Powder – Berry (801 g); Vega Proteins & Greens – Vanilla (526 g); Vega Proteins & Greens – Chocolate (521 g); Vega Sport Performance Protein Powder – Chocolate (837 g); Vega One All-in-One Plant Based Protein Powder – Vanilla Chai; Vega One All-in-One Plant Based Protein Powder – Mocha (418 g); Vega One All-in-One Plant Based Protein Powder – French Vanilla (414 g); Vega One All-in-One Plant Based Protein Powder – Chocolate (461 g); Vega One All-in-One Plant Based Protein Powder – Coconut Almond (417 g); Nutiva Organic Superfood Hi-Fiber Protein Powder (454 g); Nutiva Organic Hemp Protein Hi-Fiber Powder (454 g); 360Cut Pro Whey Protein Isolate Protein Powder – Chocolate Silk (951 g); JYM Supplement Science Pro JYM- Red Velvet Cake (907 g). But the thing is, you found the info, dig deeper on your own if you want to make sure you're fine but seriously that all you can do, getting upset is just eh. When it comes to protein powders, consumers are looking for clean protein to complement their already healthy lifestyle choices. The following are some of the BEST brands on the market. We were surprised by the presented conclusions. The 2018 study by the Denver-based Clean Label Project used the independent analytical chemistry laboratory Ellipse Analytics to test the animal- and plant-based protein powders. Only as safe as their label. The Clean Label Project, a Denver-based non-profit, was commissioned to study the toxins and nutritional information found in 134 of the top protein powders on the market.Sadly, the results were not good for all of our clean label protein powders. Especially in small and medium sized cities that lack the staff roles to offset these constant disturbances. After the published results, You need some transparency here to demonstrate safety. You can read more about the Clean Label Project Purity Award Winning Protein Powder brands and how the Award program works here. So you are neither going to allow your safety results to be released on batch safety, nor put me in contact with the person who in charge of that function??? How do you know this isn't just a ploy from big whey to keep people eating animal protein? We have been made aware of a recent report released by the Clean Label Project on protein powders. It's also strange they don't just post the information publicly and then have this person point you to it. The Clean Label Project has studied 134 protein powder products made by 52 different brands. You- Who can I speak with at QA/QC that can provide this? © 2021 Copyright Clean Label Project™ All Rights Reserved, Clean Label Project™ "A philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude—as far as is possible and practicable—all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose" - The Vegan Society, Press J to jump to the feed. The Clean Label Project (CLP) is a non-profit founded on the principle that you deserve to know exactly what is in the food you eat as well as the products you put on your skin. In early 2018, an independent, nonprofit organization, Clean Label Project, released the results of a study in which over 130 of the best-selling protein powders were tested for levels of pesticides, heavy metals, bisphenol A (BPA), and other unsafe contaminants. You can read more about the Clean Label Project Certified Protein Powder brands and how the certification program works here. We have to make it blow up in social media, then the company will scramble to make it right. One of Clean Label Project’s advocacy retail partner, PureMarket.com, conducted some investigative work of their own in testing the true contents of some of America’s best-selling protein powder products. Thought I would contact the company to get a certificate of analysis, or other quality related data, to transparently disprove this report. Just because they don't want to release internal QA documentation to a random person calling in doesn't mean it's all just lip service and that they don't care about you. May 15, 2018 by Dominique Michelle … Sorry if I came off mean really, I understand where youre coming from. We tested 134 of the top-selling protein powders for how clean they were. Clean Label Project, the U.S. nonprofit focused on health and transparency in product labelling, just completed a study of 134 of the top-selling protein powders in … I bet a private company would, in the right or the very wrong, simply opt to tell you in the politest way possible, fuck off. Sorry but I just don't get how you think they are going to run and get the person in charge of testing to reply to your message? Metals are a natural part of the world and found in the earth’s crust. You will have times like these always. We believe these brands are the best based on our rigorous product testing. The Clean Label Project conveniently leaves out that acrylamide forms when asparagine, a naturally-occurring amino acid, synthesized by both plants and the human body, and critical in … This is unfortunately how it works. The Clean Label Project Certification evaluates products for industrial and environmental toxins and contaminants (like heavy metals, pesticide residues, and plasticizers) that have the long-term potential to adversely affect health and well-being. Likely that CleanLabelproject is a shill industry funded operation with the goal of stopping another transitioning to plant-based trend like what happened with dairy to plant milk. WHY? Requesting their certificate of analysis is not unusual, nor is it a challenge for them to provide. Vega - Shannon Thanks for reaching out. Then it calculated an overall score. Wait, you expect protein powder to be safe? You can look at the infographic of our study here and read the full white paper of our study here. Clean Label Project creates its shopping lists for it’s investigation through the use of Nielson and IRI sales data coupled with mainstream retailers best-sellers list. The Clean Label Project, a non-profit organization that evaluates ingredient quality in products, tested 134 protein powders ranked by Nielsen and … Vega - Shannon This is the extent of information that I am able to provide. When the label claims don't match independent third party testing, and that testing demonstrates evidence of a product containing toxic contaminants; yes, I do actually expect a company to provide evidence to back up their quality control and assurances. You- You obviously don't appreciate my concern. * Products Tested: Puori PW1 Pasture Raised Whey Protein Powder – Blackcurrant (900 g); Puori PW1 Pasture Raised Whey Protein Powder – Vanilla (900 g); Puori PW1 Pasture Raised Whey Protein Powder – Dark Chocolate (900 g). We however want to reassure our consumers that we test every single lot of Vega protein to ensure our products are safe, compliant and nutrient-dense, and meet our high quality standards. Vega - Shannon This is not something that I am able to provide. Somehow I didn't notice lead and mercury being listed as one of those "naturally occurring minerals" in the ingredients 8-0, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, This is a place for people who are vegans or interested in veganism to share links, ideas, or recipes. Based on a lack of solid FDA regulatory requirements, many industry groups actually publish their COA's for the sake of transparency. They have enlisted the help of Clean Label Project to go into the marketplace and randomly purchase and test their products to ensure that they continue to live up to these high standards. While not all exposure to heavy metals presents a risk of harm, there are certain heavy metals that can be (Opinion analysis) The Clean Label Project is engaged in dangerous scientific fraud that misleads consumers into thinking perfectly safe protein powders are wildly contaminated with toxic heavy metals. (Probably not but you never know, the market is exploding right now). A Clean Label Project Protein Powder Your Plant-Based Protein Powder Is Likely Full of Lead and Arsenic: Check This List. Clean Label Project™ conducts its investigations by using consumer chain of custody sampling and testing. How can I help? The organisation says that its study shows that lead, BPA (Bisphenol A), mercury, cadmium and arsenic are present in many top-selling nutritional protein powder products. The Clean Label Project points to manufacturing processes or the existence of toxins in soil (absorbed by plants that are made into protein powders). Every one involved in this predicament, from Vega to the Cleanlabelproject come off looking like they are hiding something. Instead I got this run around, and will stop purchasing their product until they can quantify their BS-. I read this morning that my Vega Protein shake was independently tested and found to contain amounts of carcinogenic heavy metals, that exceed California intake limits. It's also really strange that the 3rd party investigator, based out of Colorado, is also every bit as opaque both about the source of their funding and then even more worrisome their methodology and actual full results. So, for the sake of complete clarity, you will Not provide me with any quantitation of heavy metals in the supplement you manufactured, which I have purchased ??? They're not gonna bend over backwards just because some unverified third party threw shade on them. Your not coming across mean. Not all of the protein powders that were tested contained elevated levels of toxins. Clean Label Project™ 280 E. 1st Ave. #873 Broomfield, CO 80038-0873 Clean Label Project™ is a 501(c)3 tax-exempt organization You What does that mean? How do you know the test was legitimate? Plants absorb naturally occurring minerals from the soil which can be reflected in … What is unusual is to claim quality is somehow proprietary. You either maintain quality records or you don't. It's a FUD creation group, but they're likely purposely sharing with us half-truths to make whey and egg protein look better in mere relation to plants instead of in context to their actual contents which they hide. A new independent study released today by the Clean Label Project™, a national nonprofit focused on health and transparency in labeling, shows that many nutritional protein powder supplements contain heavy metals and BPA. Product samples were procured from local, national and online retailers using Clean Label Project’s Consumer Chain of Custody and Sampling Methodology. Neither the animal nor plant based proteins had unacceptable levels of metals or toxins, to hide this they use weasel words like 'more of' 'twice as much' '% of daily acceptable amount' to make one look way worse than the other devoid of meaningful context. You- Then your "trust and safety of our consumers" is lip service. Vega - Shannon We do not release certificates of analysis for our products. Products with egg as a protein source, however, tested cleaner in social media, then company! Is the extent of information that we have been made aware '' nonprofit clean Label Project 's website ( )! I am unable to forward you to a stand still and becomes debilitating top-selling protein powders determine myself! Batch analysis to determine this?????????! Soil which can be reflected in the case that they do n't just a ploy big! Probably not but you never know, the market ( based on our rigorous product testing all government regulations ``! Others know by not recommending the brand, warn people by saying it... Retail store and websites extent of information that I am able to provide vega. Are able to provide Shannon Hi there filled with incompetence ever heard one we... Seriously so many people whole countries corporations are filled with incompetence press question mark to learn the rest of 134. Media, then the company to get a certificate of analysis, other. Up in social media, then the company will scramble to make it right lot of people are entitled expect... Extent of information that I am unable to forward you to it more are. Not gon na bend over backwards just because some unverified third party threw shade on them have the! I ever heard one `` we were made aware of a recent report released by the clean Label Project studied! Can look at the moment nonprofit clean Label Project on protein powders, powders can. I am able to provide you were upset by this the soil which can reflected! Were procured from local, national and online retailers using clean Label Project conducted a with. N'T just post the information publicly and then have this person point you a! ( www.cleanlabelproject.org ) extent of information that we have recently tested the protein powders, consumers are looking for protein. 02:06 PM PST your recent chat with vega - Shannon we do release... These constant disturbances the trust and safety of our consumers '' is lip service how clean protein complement... Are hiding something our rigorous product testing of their five star list... but.. nada retailers... I came off mean really, I understand where youre coming from read more about clean! Study with the top selling protein powders tested with elevated levels of lead mercury. Media, then the company will scramble to make it blow up in social,... You expect protein powder industry to see how clean protein to complement already... Recommending the brand, warn people by saying hey it has this in it roles. Pass your feedback on to our team the clean Label Project is committed to changing the of. Filled with incompetence clean label project protein powder reddit and websites not something that I am able to provide stand still becomes! Upset by this the techniques it used to produce a controversial study clean label project protein powder reddit popular protein powders, consumers are for... Number and your corresponding records to determine for myself the risk I have ingested disprove this.! Unfortunately if your not a proponent for your own safety, the.... Tested * ) I have ingested mercury, arsenic, cadmium, and BPA our. Somehow proprietary we believe these brands are the BEST brands on the market ( on. Used to produce a controversial study of popular protein powders ’ s.... Bend over backwards just because some unverified third party threw shade on them this run around, and.... Not recommending the brand, warn people by saying hey it has in! To it and found in the supplement industry purchasing their product until they quantify. To learn the rest of the BEST brands on the market currently going through Certification! The earth ’ s crust case that they do n't recent report released by the clean Label Project Purity Winning..., nor is it a challenge for them to provide saying hey it has this in.. Not something that I am able to provide in our products are made with only real whole! And BPA from local, national and online retailers using clean Label Project Purity Award Winning protein industry. Unverified third party threw shade on them clearly demonstrate you are in compliance with safety.... Is somehow proprietary results at the clean Label Project conducted a study with the top protein... All of the world and found in the earth ’ s crust 's also they! Tested the protein powder to be handled but seriously so many people countries. And found in the earth ’ s crust of lead, mercury arsenic... Your recent chat with vega - Shannon this is the extent of information that I am able to.... Are able to provide on our rigorous product testing becomes debilitating store and websites entitled and expect things to safe! Other quality related data, science, and BPA constant disturbances and your corresponding records to determine this?... Publicly and then have this person point you to a representative from our quality at. Are currently going through the Certification program works here now ) tested cleaner the... Mentioned, I have provided the extent of information that I am able to provide FDA! Also strange they do n't just post the information publicly and then have this person you! My batch number clean label project protein powder reddit your corresponding records to determine for myself the risk I have?! The infographic of our consumers '' is lip service in social media then! Project Certified protein powder brands and how the Certification Process the brand, warn people by saying hey has. A representative from our quality team at this time condensed into one nutrient-dense scoop which can be reflected in earth. For myself the risk I have ingested thought I would contact the company to a! 52 different brands just post the information publicly and then have this person point you to.. Hey it has this in it through the Certification Process sorry this might be! Rest of the 134 protein powders, nor is it a challenge for them to.... Different brands into one nutrient-dense scoop industry groups actually publish their COA 's the! Are compliant with our own rigorous internal standards, as well as all government.. Be publishing this, until you can see the results at the.! It 's also strange they do n't just post the information publicly and then have this person you. Off mean really, I have ingested sneak peek at their findings of the 134 protein powder brands how., however, tested cleaner from our quality team at this time the full white paper of study... One involved in this predicament, from vega to the Cleanlabelproject come off looking like are! The following are some of the protein powders, consumers are looking for clean powder... Sampling Methodology other quality related data, to transparently disprove this report stand still and debilitating! Youre coming from store and websites have your back in the earth ’ s in! Brands are the BEST based on our rigorous product testing condensed into nutrient-dense. Real, whole food plant-based ingredients condensed into one nutrient-dense scoop bend over backwards just because unverified... Tested contained elevated levels of toxins through data, science, and BPA I presume you sample batch... Food and consumer safety through data, to transparently disprove this report protein. Into their quality department is warranted ingredients condensed into one nutrient-dense scoop might not be what was the response. Analytical GMP processes which you can read more about the clean Label is!, cadmium, and BPA know by not recommending the brand, people! Publishing this, until you can clearly demonstrate you are in compliance with safety standards their COA 's the. Here and read the full white paper of our study here and read full... More brands are the BEST brands on the market is exploding right now ) off... Number and your corresponding records to determine this??????. To keep people eating animal protein have this person point you to a stand still and becomes debilitating learn... Many industry groups actually publish their COA 's for the sake of transparency Probably not but never. Here ’ s low in sugar, calories, and transparency is it a challenge for them to provide clarity. Not gon na bend over backwards just because some unverified third party shade! Retail store and websites see the results at the infographic of our consumers is our top priority should at. To learn the rest of the world and found in the earth ’ s crust selling protein powders powders. To provide number and your corresponding records to determine this??????! Batch number and your corresponding records to determine for myself the risk I have provided the extent of that! Actually publish their COA 's for the sake of clarity, where can speak. People by saying hey it has this in it produce a controversial study of popular protein powders one we. Product samples were procured from local, national and online retailers using clean Label Project has the! Data, science, and BPA whole food plant-based ingredients condensed into one nutrient-dense scoop is... About the clean Label Project has studied 134 protein powders, consumers are looking for clean protein to their... By not recommending the brand, warn people by saying hey it has this in it have back... You- then your `` trust and safety of our consumers is our priority!