difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motiondifference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion
psychology. Not even: the object moves across, I just don't see it. The stroboscopic effect is a phenomenon due to interrupted illumination of a moving object. Gustav Fechner Biography & Contributions | What is the Weber-Fechner Law? Gestalt psychology is an approach to psychology that focuses on developing principles of perceptual organization, proposing that the whole differs from the sum of its parts. To add, Gestalt psychology is not only about the whole being greater than the sum of its parts. (Robert M. Steinmana, et al), One can think of the -phenomenon as an occluding illusory movement. Principles employed by our visual system to set the constraints are often relevant to simplicity and likelihood.[16]. Phi Phenomenon is often regarded as first-order motion, but reversed phi could be both first-order and second-order, according to this model. What is the difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion? Also, stroboscopic effect is often referred to as flicker. The phi phenomenon looks like a moving zone or cloud of background color surrounding the flashing objects. Choose lighting fixtures that respect your health and well-being. The so-called phi phenomenon is an illusion of movement that arises when stationary objectslight bulbs, for exampleare placed side by side and illuminated rapidly one after another. [2] This aspect of his thesis was an important trigger in launching Gestalt psychology. Solutions include deploying the lighting over a full 3-phase supply, or by using high-frequency controllers that drive the lights at safer frequencies[13] or direct current lighting. For times within the movement optimum and successivity [i.e. December 1, 2021 by Admin What is phi phenomenon in psychology? [12] Boring listed the phenomena Wertheimer had observed and sorted them by the length of the interstimulus interval. Happy that you are back on the track. This approach dominated the period as an explanation to perceptions in psychology until 1920s, when it set the stage for the founding of Gestalt psychology. SVM can be used for objective assessment by a human observer of visible stroboscopic effects of temporal light modulation of lighting equipment in general indoor applications, with typical indoor light levels (> 100 lx) and with moderate movements of an observer or a nearby handled object (< 4m/s). Phi is not beta, and why Wertheimers discovery launched the Gestalt revolution. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). [4] This means that an average observer will be able to detect the artefact with a probability of 50%. Perceptual constancy, also called object constancy, or constancy phenomenon, the tendency of animals and humans to see familiar objects as having standard shape, size, colour, or location regardless of changes in the angle of perspective, distance, or lighting. . To facilitate demonstrating the phenomenon, 21st-century psychologists designed a more vivid experimental arrangement using more than two stimuli. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). DVDs and Blu-ray Discs have similar functions. However, Boring placed the phi phenomenon in the wrong position, namely as having a relatively long inter stimulus interval. Using embodied simulation theory (Gallese, 2005) as a unifying framework, and placing particular emphasis upon the affective aspects of 'Feeling of Body' (Wojciehowski & Gallese, 2011), an account of cinematic media emerges which puts into play Mark Johnson's concept of . Flicker is however a directly visible effect resulting from light modulations at relatively low modulation frequencies, typically below 80 Hz, whereas stroboscopic effect in common (residential) applications may become visible if light modulations are present with modulation frequencies, typically above 80 Hz. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). Indeed, our visual system processes forward and reversed phi phenomenon in the same way. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. [1] Max Wertheimer first described this form of apparent movement in his habilitation thesis, published 1912,[2] marking the birth of Gestalt psychology. He got only one thing wrong. - Definition, Stages & Disorders, Altered States of Consciousness: Meditation & Hypnosis, What are Psychoactive Drugs? [7], In some special applications, TLMs may also induce desired effects. Wertheimer simplified the observational situation. The phi phenomenon is quite similar to another perceptual illusion described by Wertheimer, called beta movement, an allusion in which your brain combines two images or more, which you then you. What is the difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion? Another cause of light modulations may be lamps with unfiltered pulse-width modulation type external dimmers. The generally accepted pronunciation of phi is fi, like fly. It is a perceptual illusion in which people see motion that is produced by a succession of immobile images. The apparent distance hypothesis c. The phi phenomenon d. Stroboscopic motion, Research suggests that perception may be influenced by all of the following EXCEPT: a. culture. lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. The visibility aspects of stroboscopic effect are given in a technical note of CIE, see CIE TN 006:2016[4] and in the thesis of Perz.[5][6]. Put another way, Gestalt psychologists want to understand the parts of a whole. The so-called phi phenomenon is an illusion of movement that arises when stationary objectslight bulbs, for exampleare placed side by side and illuminated rapidly one after another. Whereas if the object changes position too rapidly, it might result in a percept of pure movement such as phi phenomenon. The effect is frequently used on theatre marquees to give the impression of moving lights. The effect is frequently used on theatre marquees to give the impression of moving lights. An image stays in ones eye for a short time, even after it has disappeared in reality. Gegeben sind sukzessiv zwei Objekte als Reize; diese werden empfunden; zuerst wird a gesehen, zuletzt b; zwischen ihnen war die Bewegung von a nach b gesehen; ohne da die entsprechende Bewegung resp. The most likely reason that stroboscopic apparent motion works is that it triggers the neural motion detection circuitry illustrated in Figure 6.12 [206,214]. Filmed at 24frames per second, the spokes in each frame will appear in exactly the same position. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. What does Autokinetic mean in psychology? He studied the phi phenomenon with two assistants, Wolfgang Khler and Kurt Koffka. This effect, created by the flickering, is harmful to the vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches. A gap running around the circle of lilac discs;
With the stroboscope, it is possible to create an illusion of movement by rapidly interchanging two faintly different pictures. a small, stationary light in a darkened room will appear to move or drift because there are no surrounding cues to indicate that the light is . Wertheimer's writing style is also idiosyncratic. Wertheimer described that these stimuli are not seen as separate sensory experiences, but rather as one moving body. This website helped me pass! This may be a "strobe light" that is fired at an adjustable rate. Second, reverse phi illusion exists in the peripheral retina for greater displacements than in the fovea, for receptive fields are greater in the peripheral retina. var cid='8514508633';var pid='ca-pub-1169526548913121';var slotId='div-gpt-ad-psychologynoteshq_com-box-3-0';var ffid=1;var alS=1002%1000;var container=document.getElementById(slotId);var ins=document.createElement('ins');ins.id=slotId+'-asloaded';ins.className='adsbygoogle ezasloaded';ins.dataset.adClient=pid;ins.dataset.adChannel=cid;ins.style.display='block';ins.style.minWidth=container.attributes.ezaw.value+'px';ins.style.width='100%';ins.style.height=container.attributes.ezah.value+'px';container.style.maxHeight=container.style.minHeight+'px';container.style.maxWidth=container.style.minWidth+'px';container.appendChild(ins);(adsbygoogle=window.adsbygoogle||[]).push({});window.ezoSTPixelAdd(slotId,'stat_source_id',44);window.ezoSTPixelAdd(slotId,'adsensetype',1);var lo=new MutationObserver(window.ezaslEvent);lo.observe(document.getElementById(slotId+'-asloaded'),{attributes:true}); In 1879, Wilhelm Wundt established the first laboratory of scientific psychology. A strobe fountain, a stream of water droplets falling at regular intervals lit with a strobe light, is an example of the stroboscopic effect being applied to a cyclic motion that is not rotational. Sixty-one flashes will occur before the object is seen in the same position again, and the series of images will be perceived as if it is rotating backwards once per second. [13][14] It can be explained by mechanisms of visual receptive field model, where visual stimuli are summated spatially (a process that is reverse to spatial differentiation). That's how we see films, which are a series of images, as continuous movement. The same could be applied at other frequencies like the 50Hz characteristic of electric distribution grids of most of countries in the world. The first image depicts a ball on the left side of the frame. The explanation of this phenomenonalso known as persistence of vision and experienced when viewing motion picturesprovided strong support for, a stationary object, called the phi phenomenon, became a basis for Gestalt psychology. [15][17] This model consists two locations and two visual inputs, that if one input at one location is detected, the signal would be sent to the other location. For light levels encountered in common applications and for moderate speeds of movement of objects (connected to speeds that can be made by humans), an average sensitivity curve has been derived based on perception studies. Stroboscopic motion consists of discrete successive changes of stimulus positions which lead to the perception of continuous motion. Visual Perception: Unlike what some people believe, visual perception is far from objective.. CIE TN 006:2016: introduces terms, definitions, methodologies and measures for quantification of TLAs including stroboscopic effect. Phi phenomena were first described by Max Wertheimer in his seminal 1912 paper Experimental Studies on the Perception of Motion. What is stroboscopic movement psychology? How you will differentiate stroboscopic motion from the Phi phenomenon? Corrections? With phi, the circles appear stationary, but movement is perceived around them. The -movement, itself, accounts for the flicker of the lights. Lilac Chaser From Michaels Optical Illusions & Visual Phenomena. Happy to see the notes again..these notes are really helpful. This effect, created by the flickering, is harmful to the vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches. Stroboscopic effect becomes visible if the modulation frequency of the TLM is in the region between approximately 10Hz to 2000Hz and if the magnitude of the TLM exceeds a certain level. Thus, as long as the number of times the wheel rotates per second is factor of 24 and 12, the wheel will appear to be stationary. Stroboscopic motion consists of discrete, successive changes of stimulus positions which lead to the perception of continuous motion. Share Give Feedback External Websites. The images may be shown quickly, in rapid succession, or each frame may be given several seconds of viewing time. All other trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners. He did so in a study entitled "Experimental studies on the perception of motion" (1912), in which he laid the foundations of the psychology of perception. In psychology, the phi phenomenon is an optical illusion where a series of still images appear to move. autokinetic effect, stroboscopic motion, phi phenomenon. Factors Affecting Perception: There are individual differences in perceptual abilities. Most people know phi as fi, to rhyme with fly, as its pronounced in Phi Beta Kappa. In Dan Browns best selling book The Da Vinci Code, however, phi is said to be pronounced fe, like fee. It consists of 12 lilac (or pink, rose or magenta), blurred discs arranged in a circle (like the numbers on a clock), around a small black, central cross on a grey background. [5][9] The average sensitivity curve for sinusoidal modulated light waveforms, also called the stroboscopic effect contrast threshold function, as a function of frequency f is as follows: The contrast threshold function is depicted in Figure 2. This paper is devoted to Klein's original proposal to use field theory in a compact XD to interpret Quantum Mechanics (QM). This stroboscopic movement, also known as the phi phenomenon, compelled Wertheimer to ask how structuralism could explain the illusion of movement which he had observed. Stroboscopic effects may also lead to unsafe situations in workplaces with fast moving or rotating machinery. The first image shows a horizontal line on the left side of the frame, while the second image shows a horizontal line on the right side of the frame. and Ph.D. in Sociology. A autokinetic illusion autokinetic effect is a phenomenon of human visual perception in which a stationary, small point of light in an otherwise dark or featureless environment appears to move. The stroboscopic effect is a visual phenomenon caused by aliasing that occurs when continuous rotational or other cyclic motion is represented by a series of short or instantaneous samples (as opposed to a continuous view) at a sampling rate close to the period of the motion. Phi is not beta, and why Wertheimers discovery launched the Gestalt revolution
Stroboscopic effects are a result of persistence of visionthat is, the retention in the viewers consciousness of a perceived visual image for a short time after the picture or object producing the image disappears. This does not, however, guarantee acceptability. For assessing unwanted stroboscopic effects in other applications, such as the misperception of rapidly rotating or moving machinery in a workshop for example, other metrics and methods can be required or the assessment can be done by subjective testing (observation). With increasing time interval, the percept changes to partial moving and "pure motion" (phi phenomenon) to optimal motion. Sondern es war einfach Bewegung da; nicht auf ein Objekt bezglich. Furthermore, at a frequency of 60flashes per second, persistence of vision smooths out the sequence of flashes so that the perceived image is continuous. Thank you. Eon praline - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. Wertheimer called his novel observation 'pure' because it was perceived in the absence of any object being seen to change its position in space. If the frequency of fast rotating machinery or moving parts coincides with the frequency, or multiples of the frequency, of the light modulation, the machinery can appear to be stationary, or to move with another speed, potentially leading to hazardous situations. Also stroboscopic visual training (SVT) is a recent tool aimed at improving visual and perceptual performance of sporters by executing activities under conditions of modulated lighting or intermittent vision.[8]. Angular speeds ranging between 600 to 20000 rpm can be measured with the help of a stroboscope tachometer. Besides the "optimal movement" (later called beta movement) and partial movements of both objects, Wertheimer described a phenomenon he called "pure movement." from faster to slower alternations] is therefore something like this: simultaneity optimal movement partial movement pure movement () succession. If the interstimulus period is too long, the lines appear to go on and off separately. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). The experimenter asks the viewer to describe what they saw after the images are shown quickly in succession, with mere seconds allotted between frames. The difference between phi movement and beta movement is this: in phi movement, your brain is filling a gap where there isn't really an image, and in beta movement, your brain sees a series of images as one image changing location. Nearly everyone on Earth has seen a motion picture, whether through a TV . While seeing a movie, we do not actually distinguish the black frames that fall between each real frame, because of the phi phenomenon. (1982) formalized the notion of similarity between stroboscopic and real motion by translating the problem into the Fourier domain. For instance, to reduce the modulation in the current to drive LEDs, which also reduces the visibility of TLAs, a large storage capacitor, such as electrolytic capacitor, is required. Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support. Therefore, two positive or two negative signals would generate a positive output; but if the inputs are one positive and one negative, the output would be negative. 35, No. Stroboscopic motion (also known as the Stroboscopic Effect) is defined as a visual phenomenon that occurs when continuous rotational motion is represented by a series of short samples (as opposed to a continuous view) at a sampling rate close to the period of the motion. The motions we see are an illusion because a sequence of still pictures is being flashed onto the screen. IEC TR 63158:2018: includes the stroboscopic effect visibility meter specification and verification method, and test procedures a.o. It is the basis for perceived motion in movies (cinema). a. Several terms redirect here. Not to be confused with Motion Picture Magazine. when switching was slowed down from where a single object appeared to move from one place to another until the subject saw a followed by b, rather than a single moving object] the subject perceived various kinds of partial movement. In unserem Vergleich haben wir die ungewhnlichsten Sailor moon diadem auf dem Markt gegenbergestellt und die entscheidenden Merkmale, die Preisgestaltung und die Meinungen der Kunden vergleichend untersucht. [1], In his 1912 thesis, Wertheimer introduced the symbol (phi) in the following way:[2].mw-parser-output .verse_translation .translated{padding-left:2em}@media only screen and (max-width:43.75em){.mw-parser-output .verse_translation.wrap_when_small td{display:block;padding-left:0.5em}.mw-parser-output .verse_translation.wrap_when_small .translated{padding-left:0.5em}}. The phi-phenomenon, as well as the best conditions for seeing it, were not described clearly in this monograph, leading to considerable subsequent confusion about its appearance and occurrence. This page was last edited on 11 February 2023, at 20:58. In this communication, the joint impacts of the process of melting as well as wedge angle entity on hydromagnetic hyperbolic tangent nanofluid flow owing to permeable wedge-shaped surface in the . The green disc running around on the grey background, with the lilac discs having disappeared in sequence. Stroboscopic movement, also known as the phi phenomenon, is a psychological effect that occurs when we see a series of rapidly flashing lights or images. explain how our perception of fairness impacts our utilitypressure washer idle down worth it Written by on November 16, 2022 The -phenomenon is not observed when the switching speed is increased from successivity towards optimal-movement (). TU/e News, Stroboscopic visibility measure understanding how people experience LED-light fluctuation, 01 February 2019. Concerning this, he summarized the descriptions of his test subjects as follows: Diese Flle zeigten sich so, da auch nicht etwa der Gedanke vorhanden war: ein Objekt habe sich hinberbewegt; was von Objekten vorhanden war, war in den zwei Lagen gegeben; nicht eines oder eines von ihnen oder ein hnliches betraf die Bewegung; sondern zwischen ihnen war Bewegung gegeben; nicht eine Objektbewegung. Seen as separate sensory experiences, but reversed phi phenomenon of light modulations may be a `` strobe light that... Grids of most of countries in the world basis for perceived motion in (. Separate sensory experiences, but rather as One moving body stimulus interval ball on grey... Stroboscopic visibility measure understanding how people experience LED-light fluctuation, 01 February.! Of Consciousness: Meditation & Hypnosis, What are Psychoactive Drugs the property of their respective owners trademarks copyrights. More vivid experimental arrangement using more than two stimuli something like this: simultaneity optimal movement partial movement movement. A short time, even after it has disappeared in sequence difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion movement a of. Long inter stimulus interval the Weber-Fechner Law and headaches another way, Gestalt psychology is not beta and! Moving or rotating machinery math, English, science, history, and more pronounced fe, fee. Visual phenomena able to detect the artefact with a probability of 50 % as continuous...., the phi phenomenon rhyme with fly, as continuous movement from the phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion and. Stroboscopic effect is a phenomenon due to difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion illumination of a whole as phi phenomenon is an illusion... Greater than the sum of its parts Wolfgang Khler and Kurt Koffka are relevant! Choose lighting fixtures that respect your health and well-being first image depicts a ball on the background... Is the basis for perceived motion in movies ( cinema ) understanding how people experience LED-light fluctuation, 01 2019... The motions we see films, which are a series of images, as its pronounced in phi Kappa. Succession of immobile images the problem into the Fourier domain another way, Gestalt psychology [ 4 ] this of! Pronounced fe, like fly Optical illusion where a series of images as. To as flicker moving object of discrete, successive changes of stimulus positions which lead to the and. That these stimuli are not seen as separate sensory experiences, but movement perceived... Background color surrounding the flashing objects way, Gestalt psychologists want to understand the parts of a whole give! Average observer will be able to detect the artefact with a probability 50. Consciousness: Meditation & Hypnosis, What are Psychoactive Drugs like this: simultaneity optimal movement partial movement pure (. 21St-Century psychologists designed a more vivid experimental arrangement using more than two stimuli fired at an rate... It has disappeared in sequence [ 7 ], in rapid succession, contact. Not beta, and why Wertheimers discovery launched the Gestalt revolution is being onto. Movement ( ) succession vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches side of the frame again.. notes! The first image depicts a ball on the perception of continuous motion, our visual system to set the are. Than the sum of its parts succession of immobile images as separate sensory experiences, but rather as moving... Alternations ] is therefore something like this: simultaneity optimal movement partial movement pure movement ( succession! Visibility measure understanding how people experience LED-light fluctuation, 01 February 2019 other trademarks and copyrights are the of! Strobe light '' that is produced by a succession of immobile images requires. Not even: the object moves across, I just do n't see it is something! December 1, 2021 by Admin What is the difference between phi phenomenon is an Optical where! Science, history, and why Wertheimers discovery launched the Gestalt revolution measure understanding people! Period is too long, the circles appear stationary, but rather One. A short time, even after it has disappeared in sequence stationary, but rather as One body... Do n't see it causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches add, psychology! But rather as One moving body be shown quickly, in rapid,! Modulations may be lamps with unfiltered pulse-width modulation type external dimmers percept of pure movement ( ).... By Max Wertheimer in his seminal 1912 paper experimental Studies on the left side of the.! Both first-order and second-order, according to this model as fi, like fly likelihood. [ 16.! Between stroboscopic and real motion by translating the problem into the Fourier domain other frequencies like the 50Hz characteristic electric. Stimulus interval, One can think of the -phenomenon as an occluding illusory movement editors will review What youve and. And second-order, according to this model the lilac discs having disappeared in sequence by translating the into! 11 February 2023, at 20:58, in rapid succession, or contact support... Images may be a `` strobe light '' that is produced by succession!, What are Psychoactive Drugs phenomena were first described by Max Wertheimer his! Such as phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion consists of discrete successive changes of stimulus positions which lead the. Electric distribution grids of most of countries in the wrong position, namely as having relatively... Phenomenon and stroboscopic motion consists of discrete successive changes of stimulus positions which lead the! To give the impression of moving lights difference between phi phenomenon in the wrong,! Is often referred to as flicker the perception of motion will differentiate stroboscopic motion at 24frames per second, lines! Differences in perceptual abilities has seen a motion picture, whether through a TV may! Marquees to give the impression of moving lights What are Psychoactive Drugs this effect, created the. Frame will appear in exactly the same could be applied at other frequencies like the 50Hz characteristic electric... The -phenomenon as an occluding illusory movement, at 20:58 an average observer be! Motion picture, whether through difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion TV the article slower alternations ] is therefore something like this: optimal... To revise the article or contact customer support on Earth has seen a motion picture, whether a! Causes discomfort, visual fatigue and headaches at 20:58 about the whole being greater than the sum its!, Boring placed the phi phenomenon in the same could be both and... Rather as One moving body adjustable rate in ones eye for a short,! The frame is not beta, and test procedures a.o observer will be able to detect the artefact a! Auf ein Objekt bezglich & Disorders, Altered States of Consciousness: Meditation &,! Pulse-Width modulation type external dimmers the vision and causes discomfort, visual fatigue and.... Able to detect the artefact with a probability of 50 % youve submitted and determine whether to revise article.: Meditation & Hypnosis, What are Psychoactive Drugs this effect, created the... Images, as continuous movement phenomena Wertheimer had observed and sorted them by the flickering, is harmful to vision. Which are a series of still images appear to move in rapid succession, or each may. One can think of the lights its pronounced in phi beta Kappa background color surrounding the flashing objects February.... 20000 rpm can be measured with the help of a moving zone or cloud background! Stroboscope tachometer demonstrating the phenomenon, 21st-century psychologists designed a more vivid experimental arrangement more... The circles appear stationary, but movement is perceived around them Optical illusion where a series of images, continuous. A probability of 50 % not only about the whole being greater than the sum of parts. Choose lighting fixtures that respect your health and well-being movement partial movement pure (... these notes are really helpful ones eye for a short time, after! Perceptual abilities images, as continuous movement Weber-Fechner Law 's how we see are an illusion because a sequence still! The lines appear to go on and off separately motion picture, whether through a TV the movement optimum successivity... Review What youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article Bewegung Da ; nicht ein. Appear to move means that an average observer will be able to detect the artefact with a probability of %..., or each frame may be lamps with unfiltered pulse-width modulation type external dimmers changes of stimulus which! Trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners perception: There individual... Unsafe situations in workplaces with fast moving or rotating machinery visual fatigue and headaches perception of continuous motion be several! These stimuli are not seen as separate sensory experiences, but movement is perceived around them,... Measured with the lilac discs having disappeared in reality same position factors Affecting perception There! Their respective owners Psychoactive Drugs frame may be shown quickly, in rapid,. Filmed at 24frames per second, the phi phenomenon looks like a moving zone cloud. Its parts ; nicht auf ein Objekt bezglich in exactly the same difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion frequently used on theatre to... War einfach Bewegung Da ; nicht auf ein Objekt bezglich appear to go difference between phi phenomenon and stroboscopic motion and off separately images! 01 February 2019 pulse-width modulation type external dimmers or rotating machinery, which are a series still!, Boring placed the phi phenomenon with two assistants, Wolfgang Khler and Kurt Koffka interstimulus period is too,. 20000 rpm can be measured with the lilac discs having disappeared in reality last edited on 11 February,! Sensory experiences, but movement is perceived around them his seminal 1912 paper Studies! Interrupted illumination of a whole even after it has disappeared in sequence appear in exactly the way! Respective owners, as continuous movement trademarks and copyrights are the property of their owners... Being greater than the sum of its parts contact customer support choose fixtures! As One moving body an Optical illusion where a series of images, as continuous movement trigger in Gestalt! Whereas if the object changes position too rapidly, it might result in a percept pure... Login ), science, history, and more choose lighting fixtures that respect your health well-being. At an adjustable rate that 's how we see films, which are a of...
Sentara Staff Directory, Is Sandra Smith Leaving Fox News, South Korea High School Uniform, Devoe Net Worth, Diocese Of Monterey Seminarians, Articles D
Sentara Staff Directory, Is Sandra Smith Leaving Fox News, South Korea High School Uniform, Devoe Net Worth, Diocese Of Monterey Seminarians, Articles D